Dilapidations: Why Building Condition Matters Long Before the Lease Ends

In property management terms, dilapidations refers to the state of disrepair to a building that tenants or occupants are liable to repair under the terms of their lease. Dilapidation surveys assess the condition of a commercial property to determine if the tenant has met their lease obligations regarding any required repairs, maintenance or reinstatement works.

Many landlords and tenants only start thinking about dilapidations when the end of a lease approaches, but by this stage, the damage has already been done. If a tenant has been occupying a building for a long period of time especially, the property will be shaped by wear and tear, maintenance decisions and lease obligations. This means that decisions made earlier in the tenancy can directly affect the size and complexity of an initial claim.

For both landlords and tenants, knowing the true condition of a building during the tenancy gives them both more control over costs, maintenance planning and the legal risks involved.

What does dilapidations involve?

Dilapidations covers the breaches of lease obligations around repairs, maintenance, decoration and reinstatement. Although claims are usually made at the end of a commercial lease, the actual lease obligations stand from the beginning of the tenancy.

Not all of these issues are reserved until the end of a lease. Interim dilapidations are formal notices served to tenants whilst the lease is active. Essentially, because the obligations for both landlords and tenants exist during the lease, then the condition of the property is important throughout.

Why building condition should be considered during the lease

Buildings naturally deteriorate over time, no matter how well we look after them. Maintenance problems that seem minor at first can get worse, and defects that don’t seem like such a big deal at the start of a lease can end up being a major (and expensive) problem.

Having regular condition assessments can spot issues like water ingress, roof deterioration and ageing building services, so that these can be remedied before they end up becoming bigger liabilities. In the long run, this will usually be more cost-effective than waiting until numerous problems have accumulated at the end of a lease. Both tenants and landlord can benefit, as it gives more opportunity to resolve issues before they get worse.

For landlords, keeping in the loop regarding the condition of a building helps to protect its long-term value, and allows you to plan maintenance more strategically and efficiently. It also gives reassurance that the lease obligations are being met, and if there is a later need for a dilapidations claim, there will be stronger evidence to support it.

For tenants, keeping an eye on the condition of the property means they are better placed to address repairs as and when they are needed, and they can better budget for maintenance and get an understanding of the likely costs of vacating the property.

Lease obligations and repair responsibilities

Knowing the physical condition of a building alone isn’t enough to determine dilapidations: ultimately, it depends on the wording of the lease.

All commercial leases will contain different terms and clauses. Some will hold the tenant fully liable for all repair obligations, whilst others will only make them responsible for certain areas of the building, or refer to the state of the property at the beginning of the tenancy. Factors like decoration requirements, reinstatement clauses and obligations around alterations will all impact future liabilities.

Both tenants and landlords should have a good grasp of these obligations from the start, so that they can both make smarter maintenance decisions throughout the tenancy, rather than trying to figure it out once the lease has expired. Seeking advice that combines professional building surveying expertise with a knowledge of the law is key, to make sure that the property is assessed fairly alongside the obligations in the lease.

Gathering evidence for dilapidations

A lot of disputes around dilapidations kick off because there is disagreement about how defects occurred in the first place, as well as how serious they are, and whose responsibility it is to repair them.

Because of this, keeping a log of evidence throughout the tenancy can avoid these arguments. Gathering clear evidence like building surveys, inspection reports, maintenance records and photos can help to keep a log of how (and when) the property has changed over time.

Keeping a log of evidence helps both landlords and tenants. For landlords, they will have proof of how the building deteriorated during a tenancy, which can support future claims. For tenants, they can show defects that pre-date the start of their lease, and can also prove that they have conducted repairs. Maintaining good evidence can help to resolve disputes sooner, which can reduce the likelihood of it escalating to a formal dispute.

Schedule of Condition

A Schedule of Condition is an incredibly valuable tool to have, as it offers an indisputable record of the state of a property at the start of the lease. It protects tenants from being unfairly charged for damage that wasn’t their fault, and protects a landlord’s asset from neglect.

A Schedule of Condition comprises detailed photographs and written descriptions of a property at a specific point in time, acting as a baseline to prevent potential future disputes. If a lease mentions a Schedule of Condition, it stops tenants from having to return the property in a better condition than when they moved in, which reduces the chances of disputes around historic defects.

They also benefit landlords by giving a clear, agreed record of a property’s condition, so that if there is a disagreement, there is less scope for uncertainty around what problems existed when the tenancy began.

Why early surveying makes a difference

Professional surveying advice isn’t something that should only be sought after a dilapidations dispute has already occurred. Surveyors can help both tenants and landlords throughout a lease by spotting risks earlier in the tenancy.

Carrying out regular inspections can identify defects before they escalate into major problems, which also allows maintenance to be prioritised and budgeted for more efficiently. It can help to avoid unexpected (and potentially sizeable) maintenance bills at the end of a lease.

Property surveyors can also provide practical expertise for landlords and tenants, as well as Schedules of Condition. They can advise on lease obligations, assess liabilities and support negotiations in the event of a dispute. Seeking advice can not only minimise disagreements but can protect the value of a property and avoid unexpected financial exposure.

Based in the North West, Anderton Gables provides dilapidations surveying and reporting for landlords and tenants. To find out what we can do for you, get in touch.

Previous
Previous

From Reactive Repairs to Planned Maintenance: How Building Surveys Help Control Long-Term Costs

Next
Next

Buying a Commercial Property? The Building Issues You Need to Know Before Completion